NYC Leaders Demand Apology From Whoopi Goldberg Over False Staten Island Bakery Claim
Whoopi Goldberg, a co-host on The View, has found herself in hot water after making false claims about Holtermann’s Bakery, a beloved Staten Island establishment. Goldberg alleged the family-owned bakery refused to make her a batch of Charlotte Russe desserts for her birthday because of her left-wing politics. The accusation has sparked widespread backlash, with Staten Island leaders demanding a public apology for what they call defamatory remarks.
Let’s dive into the details of this brewing controversy and its impact on both Goldberg and Holtermann’s Bakery.
Whoopi Goldberg’s Allegation That Sparked Outrage
During a recent broadcast of The View, Goldberg claimed that a bakery refused her request for Charlotte Russe desserts due to political bias. She suggested that her liberal political stance was the reason behind the denial, stating:
“They said that their ovens had gone down, all kinds of stuff, but folks went and got them anyway. They did not like my politics.”
Goldberg did not initially name the bakery but implied her political affiliation played a key role in the refusal. Her comments quickly spread, leading to significant public attention and scrutiny.
Holtermann’s Bakery Responds
Holtermann’s Bakery, a 145-year-old family-run business, swiftly addressed Goldberg’s claims, clarifying that the issue was entirely unrelated to politics. According to the bakery, the delay was caused by mechanical problems with their 60-year-old boiler, which affected production on November 13, the day Goldberg attempted to place her order.
Jill Holtermann, the bakery’s owner, expressed frustration over the unfounded allegations but also gratitude for the overwhelming support the bakery has received since the incident.
“I really am overwhelmed,” Holtermann shared with The New York Post. “I’m so happy to have the support. Just to have people come out and talk and build up my business.”
Community and Leaders Rally Behind Holtermann’s Bakery
Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella held a press conference outside Holtermann’s Bakery, standing in solidarity with the family business. Fossella criticized Goldberg’s remarks, emphasizing the bakery’s reputation as a cornerstone of the Staten Island community.
“We’re here to stand up for one of the best families and businesses, not just in Staten Island but in the country,” Fossella said. “Frankly, the people who defamed the Holtermann family should apologize … for making stuff up to suit their needs.”
The controversy has unexpectedly boosted the bakery’s popularity, with orders flooding in from across the country. Holtermann reported receiving calls from as far as Alabama and Tennessee, with customers donating baked goods to schools, firehouses, and other local organizations.
Goldberg’s Political Controversies Add Fuel to the Fire
Whoopi Goldberg is no stranger to controversy. As a vocal critic of Donald Trump and conservative politics, her comments often ignite strong reactions. Over the years, Goldberg has made headlines for refusing to say Trump’s name on air and for making bold claims about his policies.
Most recently, Goldberg suggested on The View that Trump might target interracial marriages under the guise of immigration enforcement—a claim with no factual basis. Such statements have contributed to the perception that Goldberg often exaggerates or distorts facts to align with her political narrative.
The Fallout: Staten Island’s Defiant Response
The Staten Island community has rallied around Holtermann’s Bakery, turning the controversy into a show of support for the beloved establishment. Long lines of customers formed outside the bakery in the days following Goldberg’s remarks, with many expressing their loyalty to the family business.
Fossella summed up Staten Island’s sentiment perfectly:
“Judging by the line today, I think the one simple message is: You don’t mess with Staten Island.”
The outpouring of support has not only restored the bakery’s reputation but also provided a surge in business. Orders for donuts, sheet cakes, and cupcakes have come pouring in, with many customers donating the treats to local causes.
Whoopi Goldberg Faces Calls for a Public Apology
As the controversy continues to unfold, Staten Island leaders and the Holtermann family are calling on Goldberg to issue a public apology. Fossella and others argue that Goldberg’s remarks unfairly defamed a respected business and misled the public.
“Not everybody wakes up every day and thinks about politics,” Fossella said, highlighting the bakery’s nonpartisan nature and its long-standing commitment to the community.
Goldberg has yet to respond directly to these demands, but the pressure to clarify or retract her statement is mounting.
The Ripple Effect of False Claims
This incident highlights the power—and potential harm—of influential public figures making baseless accusations. While Goldberg’s remarks may have been intended as a passing comment, they had real-world consequences for the Holtermann family and their business.
At the same time, the controversy has served as a rallying point for Staten Islanders, showcasing the community’s strength and solidarity in the face of adversity.
Conclusion: A Lesson in Accountability
The clash between Whoopi Goldberg and Holtermann’s Bakery underscores the importance of accountability in public discourse. As a prominent figure with a national platform, Goldberg’s words carry weight—and with that comes the responsibility to ensure accuracy and fairness.
For Holtermann’s Bakery, this controversy, though frustrating, has ultimately strengthened its bond with the community and introduced the family-run business to new customers across the country.
Whether Goldberg will issue an apology remains to be seen, but the takeaway is clear: when a small business comes under fire, a community’s unwavering support can turn the tide. Staten Island has spoken, and the message is loud and clear: you don’t mess with their own.
